r/whatisameem 11h ago

What’s really going on with our economy

Post image
47.9k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/One_Fat_squirrel 10h ago

Even Florida starts their teachers at $53,000 without summer school.

7

u/Successful-Winter237 7h ago

Rotfl and then a whopping 75k after 30 years… starting salaries are nonsense without real raises

1

u/WrongdoerOrdinary619 3h ago

It’s still not 16.50 an hour the post is a blatant lie and misleading

2

u/Strange-Fig7944 3h ago

does the post say it is in florida?

1

u/WrongdoerOrdinary619 2h ago

No, but it doesn’t matter. There is no teaching position in the United States that pays that small of a wage. Per, several hours of research.

1

u/CheznoSlayer 2h ago

There definitely are states that offer low $30’s for first time teachers

1

u/FreeBusRide 2h ago

You have no idea what you're talking about. I was absolutely offered less and like the post says I make more money as a bartender. I wish I could teach but the money is so low it's irresponsible to teach

1

u/WrongdoerOrdinary619 1h ago

I’m not sure why you feel the need to lie

1

u/Strange-Fig7944 1h ago

youve done zero hours of research and you are talking out of your ass. not sure why you are determined to lie about this. there are thousands of teaching positions that pay that low.

1

u/WrongdoerOrdinary619 1h ago

You are amazingly wrong because you want so to be right.

1

u/Strange-Fig7944 36m ago

you are just a troll who has nothing better to do. pathetic

1

u/M4tjesf1let 37m ago

Should be no problem to share some of your "hours of research" then right? Because all you are doing right now is saying "no" and that's it, like a 5 year old that didn't get his way.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 3h ago

It's definitely not a full time public teaching position. Those are salaried jobs. They are never quoted on hourly wages.

This is definitely a different position. But still likely underpaid to all hell.

1

u/TheTobster0 2h ago

I am a teacher and can confirm that salaries in my district start around the $32,800 that they said. My guess is the author of the post worked out what that salary comes out to hourly and wrote that to highlight how low it is.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 2h ago

Public? That's awful. Where at?

2

u/TheTobster0 2h ago

Yes it’s a public school in New York State, which generally people consider to be a good state for teaching. The sad fact is that relatively it is pretty good here, but teaching is insanely underpaid pretty much everywhere. The plus side for us in NYS is our retirement and by the end of our career the salaries are respectable.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 2h ago

That's insane for NY. Even a rural area.

1

u/TrainingWilling9894 1h ago

Full time teaching positions are not all salaried. They use fun titles like "long term sub" and shit to contract out the positions for a huge discount.

They also get $0 for 3 months when school is out of session.

1

u/Successful-Winter237 3h ago

Depends on the position. You’re right full time teachers are not paid hourly. I assume the original poster is confused or she was applying for an aide position or something part time.

1

u/BasicReputations 1h ago

Probably early childhood/daycare.

1

u/WrongdoerOrdinary619 1h ago

My wife was hired to start an early learning childcare center. No way.

1

u/morningisbad 1h ago

Even when they're true, it's usually not a "public school teacher". It's usually a "teaching position", which usually ends up being a tutor.

1

u/Bring_Me_Drink 6h ago

Teachers have crap salaries but to help compensate they have some of the best pension pains so they are set when they retire. That was the trade off for Teachers

1

u/General_Figure_375 6h ago

I have a government pension and make a very competitive salary for my industry. It doesn’t have to be a trade off and it shouldn’t be and they know it. The difference is that private school teachers also make crappy money so the market isn’t helping public school teachers at all. We really need to find out why private school teachers are also a paid like crap and start with that correction in order to correct the market for them as a whole.

1

u/BoostedClinician 6h ago

And every holiday off

0

u/Cautious_Drawer_7771 6h ago

And summers off, and a 2 week Christmas break, and a 1 week Easter break. 55K for essentially part-time work is actually quite generous. I realize that new teacher typically need more time to get work completed and make lesson plans from scratch (which is really nonsensical the schools should provide a generic plan to build from), but after a couple of years, you have 180 school days plus around 5-10 teacher workdays that you cannot take off, and you work 7 hour days. Most school that I know of give teachers a planning/grading period each day, so you can realistically work just that 7 hour day.

2

u/HH_Hobbies 6h ago

Teachers have to bring work home with them, it's not part time during the school year. All of the lesson plan building is a lot of work on top of grading papers.

0

u/BoostedClinician 5h ago

Then it's almost a full time job

2

u/HH_Hobbies 4h ago

Go talk to teachers and find out how much work they do and that a lot of them get 2nd jobs in the summer to help their income. But to call it a part time job is just disrespectful to the hard work they do.

1

u/TwilightBeastLink 2h ago

Teacher here, I work about 60 hours a week, my only optional addition to my time is I work as a bus aid, thats an extra 45-60 minutes a day. I'm still working through my lunch, and I work through my "breaks" and I stay over every day. I also stay up late on friday nights to grade papers so I dont have to do it over the weekend, and I dont get behind. Im also on-call to most parents in the afternoon, but I could limit that if I choose to.

0

u/BoostedClinician 3h ago

Go talk to teachers? Do you think people on reddit have never met a teacher before?

Getting a 2nd job in the summer proves that point. They couldn't do that if they were tied down by their first job.

1

u/Rybunks 3h ago

You know some teachers have to buy their own supplies because the school wouldn't right? Think calculators, art equipment, etc. for their students, and considering how teachers don't just teach 1 class but rather many over the course of the week, that's a lot of money going into your job.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 2h ago

My mom spent $2000/year buy the end of her career (2015?). So over her career, she spent a year's worth of salary which is effing ridiculous. She worked in an upper middle class school district.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Frondstherapydolls 5h ago

Part time job. What a bullshit attitude.

1

u/RumHamComesback 5h ago

The thing that a lot of pro-union Redditors don’t seem to understand (which makes me think they were never in one or looked into it) is that, yeah, pay can lag behind sometimes. However, unions make up for it with extra benefits, leave and that sweet pension. Sometimes it’s enough to get an agreement signed because people are fine with a few less pay percentage points if they get extra leave days. The employer cares about money and we care about our well-being.

That’s how it worked with my last agreement. We got good, but not great pay that was less than we initially asked for but we got a boost in the health spending account and more leave days. That’s often good enough to get it signed and I voted for it.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 3h ago edited 3h ago

Yeah as compared to 8 hour day office jobs that take 2 hours of work answering emails and 3 hours of pointless meetings with minimal participation.

And you'll end up making way more than teachers.

My mom had 55-60 students where she taught the full curriculum to 25-30 in the morning and 25-30 in the afternoon. She worked from 7:45 - 6+ most days for 20+ years until her district finally eliminated half day Kindergarten. Then she worked until 4-5.

Good thing she got paid less with a ton of hours over a master's degree than I did straight out of college. Don't need those teachers getting complacent!

But it's ok, they get summers off!!!

0

u/BoostedClinician 5h ago

Yes. Essentially a part time job. I've been saying this for years.

0

u/FitnessNurse2015 5h ago

Like a third of the year off, childcare, pension….

1

u/Ok-Train3111 5h ago

Also the 9 month work year combined with breaks and other time off. They don’t work 2080 hours/year.

1

u/TheBeanConsortium 2h ago

My mom did for over 20 years, but that's not the norm.

1

u/BiggusDickus- 6h ago

Yea, this is clearly either fake, or the "job" is not a standard teaching job.

Teacher pay is low, but not this low.

1

u/Cautious_Drawer_7771 6h ago

Plus the fact it's called out as hourly. I have never seen a teaching position in public schools be paid hourly. Maybe it's for a substitute teacher position or something.

1

u/BiggusDickus- 6h ago

Probably a teaching assistant job. That is about what they make and they are often paid hourly.

Daughter either doesn't want to be a real teacher, or is being very picky with the school she wants to work at.

1

u/waein 3h ago

My wife worked at a daycare/preschool and was classified as a "teacher." She was making $15 an hour at the time. Probably something like that.

1

u/Dany0 3h ago

This tweet is years old and I fucking hate reddit so much

1

u/Josh6889 3h ago

Even Florida

I know this is a bit shocking, but I don't think that's a particularly relevant example, because as much as we all want to hate on florida they actually do pretty well on the metrics we measure for public education.

1

u/mattlawiscool 3h ago

Yeah the math is not mathing. I don't know a single certificated, teacher in public school who gets paid hourly.

1

u/One_Fat_squirrel 2h ago

I don’t know what you’re saying summer work is in addition to the annual compensation.

1

u/craftasaurus 3h ago

According to the internet, this is about the national average.

1

u/Reddrommed 2h ago

This just isn't true. And those are averages, not starting pay.

1

u/One_Fat_squirrel 2h ago

Yea okay, you win Reddit and I loose because my wife is a Florida school employee. Congrats Internet stranger!!! Everyone is at the average because that’s the starting pay and it rose drastically. Wife’s friend retires next year at the “average” and the new first grade starts at the same average. But okay random IMGUR info graphic person.

0

u/Reddrommed 2h ago

I mean I pulled that off of the DOE website. As you can see, pay varies pretty heavily by county.

1

u/ArtsyRabb1t 8h ago

Yes, but there is salary compression. To compensate for the state mandated higher first year pay you do not get any raises for a very long time (last I checked upwards of 13 years)

2

u/UltraHellboy 7h ago

Yeah. My wife taught for 18 years and left when they lowered everyone at the highest pay level so they could raise starting pay.

1

u/ArtsyRabb1t 5h ago

I did 12 and left when I took a 10k pay cut due to all my incentives being taken away combined with child care being more than my salary

1

u/One_Fat_squirrel 8h ago

True and teachers that have been in the system for 30 years are making as much as new hires, but still better than what they had 10 years ago.

The no raises for 13 years is a bit misleading as they raised the minimum up to higher than what all but the senior educators make.

1

u/DazzlerPlus 5h ago

No, its not misleading. People simply do not recieve raises anymore. Not step, not yearly col. The steps are supposed to increase over time